Posted by admin | Posted in Uncategorized | Posted on 02-17-2010
Last night, February 16th, I was in attendance for the City Council Meeting hoping that some form of resolution or a change in zoning might be put in place to keep organizations, like Planned Parenthood, from opening on Main Street. Neither the Resolution drafted by City Councilor Dean Tran or the Zoning Petitions put together by City Councilor Rosemary Reynolds passed in a city council vote. The question is why; and in a moment I will give you the answer.
First off, I believe that City Councilors Dean Tran, Kevin Starr, Rosemary Reynolds and Marcus DiNatale should be commended for standing their ground and pushing towards a resolution that many Fitchburg residents and business owners wanted. How do I know that people want to keep Planned Parenthood off of Main Street? From the more than 500 signatures that were collected by residents the past week in support of Councilor Dean Tran’s Resolution to prevent it.
So let’s take a deeper look at the issue in hand. The resolution presented late last night did not keep Planned Parenthood out of Fitchburg; it merely suggested that an organization of this type should be placed in a better medical suited area, like Burbank Hospital, and not smack in the middle of Fitchburg’s business district. Which, from the signatures that were collected, seems like a reasonable compromise then just saying “no”!
The reason I believe that this did not pass is because once again City Solicitor Michael Ciota backed the rights of Planned Parenthood and ignored the concerns of City Council members, residents and business owners; even admitting at one point that Tran’s Resolution could not bring any legally ramifications against the City of Fitchburg. So the question then is why is the City Solicitor not looking towards other legal solutions that the city can take to prevent Planned Parenthood from locating on Main Street, or is it because deep down certain members of City Hall actually want this organization in the center of Fitchburg’s Revitalization program?
Truth be told, when it comes to zoning, every city or town has specific laws allowing or disallowing certain businesses or organizations from opening in specific areas. How about adult entertainment? There’s an easy one to discuss. Do you see them located near a church or a school? No. And why not. Because the city prohibits such an establishment from doing so. And do you see any lawsuits pending against the city of Fitchburg because of this. No.
So then, why is the City Solicitor dictating (deciding) what the city council should do. Is the city council not a representation of the residents of Fitchburg; are they not our voice. If the people are saying no, why is it that the City Solicitor is threatening the City Council with a lawsuit on behalf of Planned Parenthood. Is it not the Councils responsibility to stand up as the voice of their constituents?
Planned Parenthood is not like other social services that Fitchburg has had before. When it comes to sexual health and education, yes, they are like Pro Health and a few other organizations in this city. But I don’t see people outside picketing against Pro Health because Pro Health is not a controversial social service that offers it clients abortions. And yes, I know that Dianne Luby (CEO Planned Parenthood in Massachusetts) said that there will be no abortion procedures done at the Fitchburg location (which I think in the long run is a lie) but the simple fact is that Planned Parenthood does do abortions at other facilities. Why does this matter? Because no matter what, you’re going to have protesters outside of their location and the two combined are going to bring an even larger negative stigma to Main Street.
The people of Main Street, the business owners and the residents who shop here, have worked hard to bring life back to downtown. When crime overran this street, it was people of Fitchburg who stood up and fought back to regain what was theirs. We believed City Hall when they told us that Fitchburg was rebuilding and that at some point it might be able to return to its days when people truly had pride in their city.
But now the City Solicitor is telling us that we can’t fight; that an organization who knows nothing about the city of Fitchburg has more rights then the people who live here. Shame on you Mr. Ciota! And shame on the city councilors who backed down to him!
You wanted the people of Fitchburg to help you rebuild and they have. We believed in you. I believed in you; that the city was sincere in revitalizing Main Street. People have jeopardized everything they have to keep their homes and their businesses in Fitchburg, even when it was at its worst. But now when residents are asking you to stand up for us, you sit down.
Businesses are going to leave, and the businesses you hoped would come to Main Street won’t look twice at us. You know that this fact and in doing so Fitchburg will lose out on extra revenue while increasing citywide unemployment.
Is this what you wanted? Is this how you pictured Fitchburg’s rebirth? In the middle of more controversy?
If you allow Planned Parenthood to open on Main Street, you’ll be just as guilty as they are for putting an end to Fitchburg’s revitalization. You’ll be the nail and they’ll be the hammer!
It’s time for the City Council to stand up and remind City Solicitor Ciota that he works for the city and not Planned Parenthood. Backing down to the threat of a lawsuit only encourages organizations to take advantage of a situation. Fighting back, however, will show that Fitchburg has had enough of the bullying and the threats. It’s time for the City Council to draw the line.
The people are speaking. You need to listen!
